Annotated
Media Anthropology Bibliography
A
-
Abu-Lughod,
L. 2005. Dramas of nationhood: the politics of television
in Egypt. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago
Press.
Lila Abu-Lughod presents the shifting and competing perspectives
reflected in television serials in contemporary Egypt.
She understands television as a 'key institution' for
analyzing nation building because it combines the cultural
with the sociopolitical, reflects the perspective of the
public as well as the domestic sphere and, most importantly,
brings female viewers into play. She calls the particular
Egyptian form of television serials 'domestic dramas'
that deal with the everyday-life of ordinary people. In
her analysis, Abu-Lughod approaches the serials from different
points of view by means of a multi-sited approach. First,
she examines the interlocking networks of script writers,
directors, producers, actors and critics, who design and
produce the serials for the impoverished masses. Second,
she watches TV and discusses its lessons and meanings
with two different groups of marginalized women: women
in the villages of a rural, underdeveloped region of Upper
Egypt and women who work as domestic servants in Cairo.
(Heike Drotbohm, Freiburg)
Lila Abu-Lughod charts the movement of 'melodramatic serials'
from encompassing, in Schudson's (1984) terms, a 'development
realism' media aesthetic towards 'capitalist realism',
following the reorganization of the Egyptian television
industry. She questions capitalist realism's ability to
draw people from divergent socioeconomic backgrounds into
the ethos of the nation-state. Through an implicit practical
application of Marcus' (1995) notion of multi-sited ethnography,
Abu-Lughod examines how these television serials relate
to reality for the production elite and post-production
critics, and two groups of subaltern viewers. By establishing
the production elite as members of the Egyptian intelligentsia,
Abu-Lughod crystallizes their role in the generation of
social hegemony, and illustrates the patronization sensed
by her disadvantaged informants, as a result of misunderstandings
about their lived experiences.
(Mark Paul Highfield, Aberdeen)
Published reviews:
Drotbohm, H. 2005. Critique of Anthropology, 25, 437-438.
Highfield, M.P. 2006. Social Anthropology, 14/2, 273-294.
-
Allen,
S. (ed.). 1994. Media anthropology. Informing global
citizens. Westport, Bergin: Garvey.
One of the first approaches to media anthropology, which
divided it into the applied and theoretical branches.
The majority of the contributors focus on the first branch.
The applied media anthropology includes tools for anthropologists
to better communicate with media and for journalists to
understand the anthropologists universe.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
-
Andreassen,
R. 2005. The Mass Media's Construction of Gender, Race, Sexuality and Nationality. An
Analysis of the Danish News Media's Communication about Visible Minorities from 1970 to 2004.
Unpublished PhD thesis: Department of History, University of Toronto.
Online: http://www.rikkeandreassen.dk/publikationer.html
Based on the analyses of television primetime news clips and national newspaper articles from the 1970s to the 2000s,
the
dissertation throws light on how the news media have represented visible minorities (refugees,
immigrants and their descendants) in Denmark. By drawing upon post-colonial theory, queer theory,
feminism, media theory and theories of nationalism, the dissertation examines how this news
coverage has participated in the construction of Danish nationality as well in the construction of
gender, race, sexuality and whiteness.
(Rikke Andreassen, Malmö)
-
Ang,
I. 1991. Desperately seeking the audience. London:
Routledge.
This is a work that looks into the issue of how media
organisations construct their images of their audiences,
through institutional research practices and management
routines. It provides background for mainly production
but also 'audience' ethnographies.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
-
Ang,
I. 1996. Living room wars. London: Routledge.
This
is a follow up work to Desperately seeking the audience.
Whilst the former focussed more on production side constructions
of the 'audience' this work is more focussed on audience
research, and as the title suggests, with an emphasis
on issues of difference. This includes considerations
of gendered audiences, and critical accounts of notions
of 'global culture'.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
-
Ardevol,
E. and J. Grau. 2005. AntropologÌa de los Media.
Actas del Congreso de AntropologÌa. Seville:
AA.EE.
This is a collection of papers from a meeting of anthropologists
held in Seville in September 2005. Most papers are in
Spanish, but there are also one each in Catalan, Portuguese
and English. Papers on the Internet predominate (on online
dating, cyberfeminism, weblogs, identity formation, cultural
epidemiology, diasporas, virtual communities). There are
also pieces on biomedia, video activism, advertising,
film, radio and TV. The anthropological emphasis is more
cultural than social. The editors identify the relationship
between media and cultural processes (or culture) as the
thread running through the papers. They also suggest that
contributors go beyond media instrumentalism to explore
how media are engaged in re-presenting reality and re-elaborating
subjective and sensorial experiences.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Ardèvol,
E. and N. Muntañola (eds.). 2004. Representación
y cultura audiovisual en la sociedad contemporánea.
Barcelona: UOC.
This interdisciplinary volume provides a conceptual framework
for the understanding of the role of images in our contemporary
societies. It deals with classical and more recent theories
about culture and ways of seeing, the social imaginary
and its relation with invention and convention, the use
of visual representations in conforming identity and alterity,
the subject construction of current image technologies
such as photography, cinema, television or virtual reality,
and image consumption in popular culture. A basic toolkit
for the critical analysis of image as social practice.
(Elisenda Ardèvol, Barcelona)
-
Asad,
T. 1990. 'Ethnography, literature and politics: Some readings
and uses of Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses', Cultural
Anthropology 5(3): 239-269.
Asad is exceptionally good at demonstrating the extent
to which most of the protests about Rushdie's portrayals
of the prophet (which, intratextually, were part of a
madman's drug-induced dreams and hence not really representations
of the prophet at all) were very much about other issues
for which the garbled accounts of Rushdie's work allowed
people to coalesce and rally.
(Mark Peterson, Miami)
-
Askew,
K. and R.R. Wilk (eds.). 2002. The anthropology of
media. London: Blackwell.
This
reader contains a collection of important articles on
the anthropological study of media, culture, and society.
The book is divided into five thematic parts. Part one
deals with media technologies and their relation to 'truth'.
Part two and three look from different angles at the phenomenon
of representation in the context of media: representing
others and representing selves. The fourth part turns
the focus to the active reception of mass media. Finally,
the fifth part of the reader presents a melange of perspectives
on national, post-colonial, and global projects and their
influence on media usage.
(Philipp Budka, Vienna)
One of the most important collections of studies devoted
to this field. The reader is focused more on the media
as transmission channel and less on media content. The
authors study both the production and the consumption
of media by non-western groups and the role of mass media
(especially as entertainment) in sustaining national or
regional identities.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
This is a self-declared attempt to institute anthropology
of media as a subfield, by producing an introductory reader
to the topic. It has some classic texts (McLuhan, Williams)
and some interesting production and audience ethnographic
pieces. It also tackles some of the debates on globalisation
from a media anthropology type of perspective.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
Published review:
Durington, M. 2004. American Ethnologist 31 (1),
February 2004.
Online: http://www.aaanet.org/aes/bkreviews/result_details.cfm?bk_id=3038
-
Aspers,
P. 2001. Markets in fashion. A phenomenological approach.
Stockholm: City University Press.
This
book provides a detailed account of the fashion photography
market, making use of Harrison White's theories and distinguishing
between 'aesthetic' and 'economic' markets.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Auslander,
Ph. 1999. Liveness. Performance in a mediatized culture.
London: Routledge.
The study starts with the description of the interrelations
between live performances and mediatized presentations
in contemporary forums for cultural consumption. Examples
are taken from the theatre, TV, (rock) music and the court.
Auslander analyses which concepts of liveness have developed
in these arenas, how they have changed with the introduction
and spread of new media technologies and which role they
play in reception processes.
(Ursula Rao, Halle)
B
-
Bakker,
F.L. 2005. 'The image of Muhammad in The Message, the
first and only feature film about the Prophet of Islam',
Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations 7(1): 77-93.
This paper covers the tremendous efforts the international
crew underwent to get approval from Al-Azhar and the Sh'ite
Council in Lebanon (also the two groups Abu-Laban says
his group originally showed the binder of cartoons to),
their efforts to stay within the fatwa, their ultimate
failure (although this feature-length movie about the
prophet does not at any point represent the Prophet),
and the controversies that followed their decision to
release it anyway.
(Mark Peterson, Miami)
-
Barber,
K. 2000. The Generation of Plays. Yoruba Popular Life
in Theater. Indiana University Press.
Based upon archival research and participant observation
as an actress, Karin Barber presents a detailed account
of the transformations Yoruba popular theatre has gone
through from the 1940s to the 1980s. This work is very
rich in ethnographic material that she drew from her cooperation
with one theatre company, Oyin AdjÈjobi Theater
Company. The personalities of the actors, the creation
of plays (from the germ of an idea to the stagings), the
interaction with the audiences, and the need for a moral
lesson have been examined in great detail. Of most interest
for media anthropologists is the chapter 'Television,
film and video'. It shows how the visual media alter ways
of sociality for the actors, preparations of plays, contact
with their audience, and even the slots of the performed
stories.
(Katrien Pype, Leuven)
-
Bausinger,
H. 1984. 'Media, technology and daily life', Media,
Culture and Society 6: 343-351.
An early theoretical call for the empirical study not
of a single medium but of media as ensembles. The author
suggests that media are seldom used completely or with
full concentration, that they are shot through with non-media
activities, and that even reading the newspaper is a collective
activity. The argument is nicely illustrated with a day
in the life of an imaginary West German family, the Meiers.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Beck,
R.M. and F. Wittmann (eds.). 2004. African Media Cultures.
Transdisciplinary Perspectives / Cultures de Médias
en Afrique. Perspectives Transdisciplinaires. Cologne:
Ruediger Koeppe Verlag.
The aim of this volume is to display the wide range of
media cultures in African societies. All contributors
agree on the importance of the cultural, social or historical
contextualization of the material: press in The Gambia
and Senegal, comics in Cameroon, wall paintings in Ethipia,
speaking potlids from Angola, proverbs in Benin, local
language writers in Uganda, the griot in Niger, music
in Kenya, Tanzania and Congo, radio in Ghana, television
in Ivory Coast, horror movies in Nigeria, internet in
Senegal and an essay on mobile phones in Burkina Faso.
The heterogeneity of the communication processes, their
multiplicity and complexity explains the range of theoretical
and methodological approaches in the volume. It testifies
to the wealth of African media and their appropriation,
and emphasizes how incredibly neglected this topic has
been so far. The book unites 15 scholars from three continents,
eight countries and from across the disciplines to map
the media cultures in Africa by analyzing their actors,
forms, practices, regulations and usages in past and present
times. It is intended to serve as an introduction for
Africanists from Social Anthropology, History, Linguistics
or Political Studies interested in media, but also for
scholars of Media and Communication Studies in search
of information in African media cultures.
(Frank Wittmann, Fribourg)
-
Becker,
H. 1982. Art worlds. Berkeley: University of California
Press.
This is a classic account of how art worlds - and, by
extension, media worlds - operate as 'networks of cooperating
people', including different types of artists, critics,
dealers, and so on.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Benson,
R. and E. Neveu (eds.). 2005. Bourdieu and the Journalistic
Field. Cambridge and Malden, MA: Polity Press.
The book is an attempt of reflecting on the possible ways
of applying Bourdieuís field theory to the studies
of media and journalism. It consists of three parts: theoretical,
empirical comparative and critical. Apart from the lecture
of Bourdieu 'The Political Field, the Social Field and
the Journalistic Field', there are articles by Michael
Schudson, Bourdieu's cooperates from the journalism research
group at the Centre for European Sociology and others.
The book is a valuable contribution to the formation and
development of the field theory of journalism. However,
readers could be slightly disappointed by it if they were
expecting to find a systematic picture of the field.
(Anna Horolets, Warsaw)
Published review:
Couldry, N. 2007. Bourdieu and the media: the promise and the limits of theory.
Theory and Society, Vol. 26, No.2: 209-213.
Online: http://www.springerlink.com/content/j684184462n12275/
Horolets, A. 2007. Social Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale, No. 15: 113-114.
Online:
blackwell-synergy.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1469-8676.2007.00004_7.x (PDF, 144 KB)
-
Bird,
S.E. 1992. For enquiring minds: A cultural study of
supermarket tabloids. Knoxville: University of Tennessee
Press.
One of the first of what remains a small number of case
studies of a media genre by a cultural anthropologist.
This anthropological study of American supermarket tabloids
includes textual analysis of the papers in terms of their
connections with traditional folkloric themes, as well
as analyses based on ethnographic studies of tabloid writers
and readers, and points the way to the further serious
study of media by anthropologists.
(Elisabeth Bird, South Florida)
-
Bird,
S.E. 1992. 'Travels in Nowhere Land: Ethnography and the
"Impossible Audience"', Critical Studies
in Mass Communication, 9 (3): 250-260.
An anthropological intervention in the debate about how
to study the media audience ethnographically, arguing
against the post-modern position that ethnography is virtually
impossible and that the media 'audience'
essentially does not exist.
(Elisabeth Bird, South Florida)
-
Bird,
S. E. (ed.). 1996. Dressing in feathers: The construction
of the Indian in American popular culture. Boulder,
CO: Westview Press/Harper Collins.
Edited collection interdisciplinary essays on representation
of American Indians in popular media. Contributors include
scholars from anthropology, communication, American Studies,
and history; they provide essays on topics from 19th Century
trade cards, photographs, and theatrical productions,
through movies, TV, comics, tourist postcards, and museum
exhibits.
(Elisabeth Bird, South Florida)
Published review:
Carr, H. 1998. Journal
of American Studies 32 (1): 128-129.
(PDF, 440 KB)
-
Bird,
S. E. 2003. The audience in everyday life: Living in
a media world. New York: Routledge.
This book brings together several ethnographic studies
on the role of the media in everyday life. Beginning with
an introductory chapter on anthropology and media, the
book then offers chapters on: The role of news in interrogating
moral boundaries, arguing that news 'stories'
need to be understood as ongoing dialog, rather than texts;
the creation of a female community through TV fan activities;
a case study of the relationship between news and oral
tradition; the question of aesthetic judgment in popular
media studies, and how ethnographic studies can illuminate
this; and an exploration of how Native American and Anglo
audiences respond to media representations. The book closes
with a discussion of the future of media ethnography.
The book won the 2004 Best Book Award from the International
Communication Association.
(Elisabeth Bird, South Florida)
-
Bird,
S.E. and R.W. Dardenne. 1997. 'Myth, chronicle and story:
Exploring the narrative qualities of news', in D. Berkowitz
(ed.), Social Meanings of News: A Text Reader,
333-350. Sage Publications. (First published 1988).
This article was one of the first to look at news as functioning
like myth, taking the study of news beyond textual analysis
toward a serious consideration of the cultural role of
news in drawing boundaries, maintaining authority, and
naturalizing ideology.
(Elisabeth Bird, South Florida)
-
Born,
G. 1997. 'Computer software as a medium: textuality, orality
and sociality in an artificial intelligence research culture'
in M. Banks and H. Morphy (eds.), Rethinking Visual
Anthropology. New Haven and London: Yale University
Press.
A fascinating ethnographic and iconographic analysis of
IRCAM, 'a computer music research centre generously funded
by the French state'. Born shows how IRCAM's computer
programmers fail to properly document their work. This
makes the entire organisation reliant on two ancient human
achievements: orality and sociality.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Bräuchler,
B. 2005. Cyberidentities at War: Der Molukkenkonflikt
im Internet. Bielefeld: transcript.
Conflicting parties worldwide increasingly use the internet
in a strategic way. By extending into cyberspace, local
conflicts acquire a new global dimension. Based on ethnographic
research on the online activities of Christian and Muslim
actors in the Moluccan conflict (1999-2002) this study
investigates processes of identity construction and community
building on the internet. The author thus makes an innovative
contribution to conflict and internet research and methodologically
paves the way for a new cyber anthropology.
Online chapter: http://www.transcript-verlag.de/ts287/ts287.htm
(Birgit Braeuchler, Munich)
Published reviews:
Online
review by Nils Zurawski, Hamburg: http://www.kommunikation-gesellschaft.de/
Postill, J. 2006. Ethnos,
April 2006. (PDF, 82 KB)
-
Brechon,
P. and J.P. Willaime (eds.). 2000. Medias et religion
en mirroir. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
This collection of studies underlines the role of media
in the distribution of religious representations. The
most attractive studies, from the media anthropology perspective,
refer to religious ceremonies as media events and to the
reception of the religious services through television.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
-
Budka,
Ph. and M. Kremser. 2004. 'CyberAnthropology
- Anthropology of CyberCulture', in S. Khittel, B.
Plankensteiner and M. Six-Hohenbalken (eds.), Contemporary
issues in socio-cultural anthropology. Perspectives and
research activities from Austria, 213-226. Vienna:
Loecker. (PDF, 715 KB)
This article investigates the historical development,
the major theories and the ethnographic domains of an
anthropology of cyberculture. In doing so, the authors
use Arturo Escobar's influential paper on cyberanthropology,
written in 1994, and connect potential research questions
posed in this text with research projects recently conducted
at the Viennese Department of Social and Cultural Anthropology.
The authors conclude that the anthropology of cyberculture
is not a new sub-discipline of socio-cultural anthropology,
but a new field of inquiry with clear-cut domains and
areas of ethnographic research.
(Philipp Budka, Vienna)
C
-
Carey,
J. (ed.). 1988. Media, myth and narratives. London:
Sage Publications.
One of the most provocative books in this field. The studies
are concerned with the media contents, particularly to
the relation between the themes distributed by mass media
and myth and between the structure of the journalistic
discourse and the narrative mechanisms.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
-
Coman,
M. 2003. Pour une anthropolgie des medias. Grenoble:
Presses Universitaires de Grenoble.
The largest synthesis of debates and studies with use
the concepts of myth and ritual in media analysis. The
volume includes also a proposal for a theory of media
anthropology, case studies, and an analysis of the way
the anthropologic perspective puts in a new light some
of the basic concepts of media studies.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
-
Couldry,
N. 2003. Media rituals. A critical approach. London:
Routledge.
Draws on anthropological theories of ritual to critique
media studies approaches to ritual. Argues that media
rituals are actions that reproduce the myth of the media
as privileged access points to the centre of society -
the myth of the mediated centre.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
Published reviews:
Postill, J. 2004. Anthropological Theory, February
2004.
Rothenbuhler, E.W. 2004. European Journal of Communication
19 (3).
Wilmore, M. 2003. Social Anthropology 11 (3).
D
-
Dagron,
A.G. 2001. Making waves. Stories of participatory communication
for social change. New York: Rokefeller Foundation.
Whilst
not strictly media anthropology, this is a set of case
studies of participatory communications projects in the
developing world. It is a diverse set of case studies,
not confined merely to the activities of NGOs. Anthropologists
looking for interesting and unusual uses of media to investigate
might want to use this as a reference.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
-
Davila, A. 2001. Latinos, Inc.: The Marketing and Making of a People.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Arlene Davila examines production processes in advertising industry and how
media technologies play a crucial role in the shaping of (trans)national
cultures and identities. She analyzes "Latino" media and particularly
advertising agencies in the processes of community formation and
transformation at local and transnational levels.
(Yesim Kaptan, Indiana)
-
Debray,
R. 1996. Media manifestos. London and New York:
Verso.
In this book Debray outlines his proposed science of media,
or mediology. He argues that a semiotics of the image
is unfeasible, for images transgress rhetorics. Images
apprehend time instantly which contrasts with the linearity
of texts. Semioticians have tried to 'conquer' the image
by studying films and cartoon strips but images are simple,
not complicated; they short-circuit reality.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Deger, J. 2006. Shimmering Screens: Making Media in an Aboriginal Community.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Excellent recent work of Jennifer Deger on her long term work with the Yolngu community in Gapuwiyak, which looks at the negotiation of
various media - photography, radio, video - with Yolngu cosmologies and concerns.
(Faye Ginsburg, New York)
-
Dickey,
S. 1997. 'Anthropology and its contributions to studies
of mass media', International Social Science Journal
XLIX (3): 413-427.
A useful, yet often neglected, overview of media anthropology
in the late 1990s.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Doostdar, A. 2004. 'The Vulgar Spirit of Blogging: On Language, Culture, and Power in Persian Weblogestan',
American Anthropologist 106 (4): 651-663.
In an ethnographic case study of a particular debate in the Iranian
blogosphere, this paper concentrates on overlapping discourses of the
'proper' use of Persian, free speech, and the 'vulgar' potential of blogs. Alireza Doostdar uses a linguistic analysis based on Bakhtin's
concept of the speech genre and dialogue, and the 'deep play' approach of Geertz. He also traces some connections between on and offline
Persian speech patterns and social patterns.
(Julian Hopkins, Kuala Lumpur)
-
Drackle,
D. 1999. 'Medienethnologie: Eine Option auf die Zukunft
[Media anthropology: a future option]' in W. Kotot and
D. Drackle (eds.), Wozu Ethnologie? [Why Anthropology?].
Berlin: Dietrich Reimer Verlag.
An introduction to the emerging anthropology of media,
in both senses of this term: as the anthropological study
of media, and as the dissemination of anthropological
knowledge to the general public. Particularly useful for
undergraduate teaching.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
E
-
Eriksen,
T.H. 2006. Engaging anthropology: The case for a public
presence. Oxford: Berg.
A well-argued statement for a stronger anthropological
presence in the public realm, backed up with examples
from the authorís own sustained engagement with
the Norwegian press. Eriksen suggests that present day
anthropologists have to rediscover the discipline's old
craft of weaving narrative and analysis to reach a wider
audience and help to shape the public sphere.
Chapter 1 freely available online at http://folk.uio.no/geirthe/Engaging_Anthropology.html
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Experience
Rich Anthropology Project.
Online: http://www.era.anthropology.ac.uk
See especially the archive of Farnham Rehfisch's field
photographs, the Kinship Editor for drawing genealogies
and work on the Powell Cotton museum including digitised
field films.
(David Zeitlyn, Kent)
F
-
Faubion,
J.D. 1999. 'Figuring David Koresh' in Marcus, G. (ed.),
Critical anthropology now. Unexpected contexts, shifting
constituencies, changing agendas. School of American
Research Press.
This piece is totally constructed through juxtaposition
of newspaper stories on the Waco event. This could be
read as a supplementary piece to Faubion's ethnography
on Waco. But still it is valuable and creative piece even
without seeing the whole ethnography.
(Erkan Saka, Rice)
-
Fischer,
C. S. 1992. America calling: A social history of the
telephone to 1940. Berkeley, CA, University of California
Press.
A highly accessible work discussing the social history
of the telephone, noting that crises of moral panic and
modernity (often perceived as novel aspects of the internet)
were experienced a hundred years ago with the introduction
of the telephone. Similarly, the telephone was appropriated
and integrated by users in ways unanticipated and not
necessarily welcomed by commercial organisations and policy
makers, perhaps reinforcing as much as modifying social
and cultural patterns.
(Mark Gaved, Open University)
-
Fishman, M. 1980. Manufacturing the News. London: University of Texas Press.
The book analyses how social facts are constructed by journalists and why particular issues are highlighted while others - overlooked. Social
reality cannot be understood outside of its context. The author cites the example of crime wave incident that became a popular issue in New York in 1979. Despite the official report of reduction
in the number of crimes in the City, the journalists continued reporting growth in the number of crimes. The author argues that there are four ways through which newsmakers produce news: 1)
detect occurrence, 2) interpret them as meaningful events, 3) investigate their factual character, and 4) assemble them into stories.
(Taberez A. Neyazi, Singapore)
-
Fiske,
J. 1989. Television culture. London: Routledge.
Here
Fiske outlines his ideas of 'active audiences' (in chapter
5) also responding to some of the criticisms of his notions
of 'semiological democracy'. For anthropologists this
provides a serious look at issues of multiple meaning
and the problems of interpretation in 'audience' readings
of television.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
-
Foster,
R.J. 2002. Materializing the nation. Commodities, consumption
and media in Papua New Guinea. Blooington and Indianapolis:
Indiana University Press.
In this highly readable monograph Foster finds compelling
evidence that Papua New Guinea (PNG), independent from
Australia only since 1975, is already far more than an
imagined political community (Anderson). He analyses Coca-Cola
advertising, law and order campaigns,letters to the English-language
press, millennial cults, betel nut chewing and other practices,
and reports the emergence of a distinctly PNG public culture.
Foster follows Billig in stressing the significance of
banal everyday practices in the maintenance of a national
public culture, whether they be reading the PNG weather
forecast or viewing street hoardings in Tok Pisin, the
national language.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
Published
review:
Postill, J. 2004. Ethnos 69: 1.
G
-
Ginsburg,
F.D., L. Abu-Lughod and B. Larkin (eds.). 2002. Media
worlds. Anthropology on new terrain. Berkeley: University
of California Press.
This collection of anthropological papers covers a wide
range of media phenomena: from the use of mass media by
minority groups for cultural activism, via the diverse
connections between national politics and media, to the
study of transnational media circuits. The last two sections
of the volume return to the social sites of media production
and the social life of technology. By exploring socio-cultural
processes of media consumption, production, and circulation,
the book highlights the importance of ethnographic fieldwork
in the study of media.
(Philipp Budka, Vienna)
Another reader that puts together numerous studies of
specialists in visual anthropology and in media studies.
The reader offers a great variety of case studies and
some provocative theoretical debates.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
Published review:
Durington, M. 2004. American Ethnologist 31 (1),
February 2004.
Online: http://www.aaanet.org/aes/bkreviews/result_details.cfm?bk_id=3038
-
Godzic,
W. 2004. Telewizja i jej gatunki (po Wielkim Bracie)
[Television and its genres (after Big Brother)]. Krakow:
Universitas.
Based on the research of Polish television production
and consumption in the last years, this book is a reflection
on the contemporary developments in the system of television
genres. Several chapters are devoted to the processes
occurring in this system: the orientation on and saturation
with the news and the growing popularity of reality shows
and sitcoms. The emergence and spread of the new genres
have significant bearings on human condition. The author
suggests that after the Panopticon of Michel Foucault
and Synopticon of Zygmunt Bauman there comes an era of
Demopticon. In Demopticon the viewers who search for meanings
on the TV screens turn cameras on themselves, thus becoming
agents of producing cultural meaning.
(Wieslaw Godzic, Warsaw)
-
Golebiewska,
M. 2003. Demontaz atrakcji. [Demontage of attraction.
On the aesthetics of audiovisuality]. Gdansk: slowo/obraz
terytoria.
The book is concerned with the epistemological and aesthetic
status of the audiovisual message in the contemporary
culture of media. The changes in the anthropological definitions
are linked to those occuring in human perception under
the influence of media and technology. The book applies
the conception of 'attraction' (proposed by Sergey Eisenstein)
to the interpretation of phenomena of the contemporary
popular culture. The second main point of reference is
the conception of the montage and demontage (dismantling)
of human consciousness, proposed and applied by Walter
Benjamin to the description of shifts of human perception
and subjectivity at the beginning of the 20th century,
when new technologies had been significantly influencing
the sphere of culture. The analytical part of the book
concentrates on the study of the film and television as
postmodernist arts, the specificity of the digital image,
the self-reference of advertising messages and the social
advertising as an example of 'anaesthetics'. The analyses
acquire a status of demontage - the mode of cultural self-reference
and individual self-cognition typical of contemporary
times.
(Maria Golebiewska, Warsaw)
-
Goody,
J. 1997. Representations and contradictions. Ambivalence
towards images, theatre, fiction, relics and sexuality.
Oxford: Blackwell.
For the author, representations are a re-presenting of
that which is absent. As language users, humans cannot
avoid but having doubts about the ontological status of
representations. These doubts worsen with the advent of
writing, leading in some literate societies to iconoclasm,
the rejection of visual representations. A wonderful media
survey ranging wide across historical periods and geographical
areas, it offers some invaluable insights into the unintended
effects of a new media practice (writing) upon an older
media practice (painting).
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Gupta,
A. 1995. 'Blurred boundaries: the discourse of corruption,
the culture of politics and the imagined state', American
Ethnologist. 22: 375-402.
This is a very creatively made piece of audience research
that shows how newspapers actually serve as the media
to disseminate discourses and how Benedict Anderson's
ideas can be elaborated ethnographically.
(Erkan Saka, Rice)
H
-
Hoybye, M.T.,
Johansen, C. and T. Tjornhoj-Thomsen. 2005. 'Online
interaction. Effects of storytelling in an internet breast
cancer support group.' Psychooncology 14(3):
211-220. (PDF, 124 KB)
This ethnographic study explores how support groups on
the internet forms strategies of empowerment to women
with breast cancer. It investigates the storytelling emerging
on the Scandinavian Breast Cancer Mailing list that provides
a passage from isolation to inclusion in a new social
world. Thus storytelling is analysed as a way of acting
on experience and mediating social transformation. Our
findings showed that the internet was considered a means
for finding ways of living with breast cancer, which suggests
that internet support groups have important potential
for the rehabilitation of cancer patients.
(Mette Terp Hoybye, Copenhagen)
I
-
Iwabuchi,
K. 2002. Recentering globalization. Popular culture
and Japanese transnationalism. Durham and London:
Duke University Press.
Iwabuchi
as a cultural studies scholar who has done detailed studies
of the reception of, in particular Japanese, television
programmes in the east Asian region. On this basis, he
provides a refreshingly different take on global flows.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
J
-
Jarecka,
U. 1999. Swiat wideoklipu [The World of Music Videos].
Warsaw: Oficyna Naukowa.
The book treats video-clip as a new language of the visual
and both cause and effect of its changes. In the first
part the ideas and cultural processes, which formed the
new version of the iconosphere are analysed. While examining
the emergence of an ocularcentric perspective in Western
culture, the author focuses on the main aspects of scopic
regimes and the aesthetics of vanishing. The historical
moment and features of the new media era, electronic images
in particular, are considered in the interpretation of
the visual culture. The second part of the book is devoted
to the analyses of the audiovisual material from MTV,
Viva, Onyx and MCM music television channels. The types
of music videos - political, contemplative, consumption-oriented
and beauty-oriented - match the flexible sensitivity of
the audience. The author investigates the intertextuality
of messages, symbols and archetypes appearing in music
videos, especially in the portraits of men (e.g. eroticism)
and in experiments with body images. Alternative worlds
of performances in music videos are an example of the
aesthetics of vanishing at work. The analyses are subordinated
to three types of space in the visual: the real, the quasi-real
and the utopian (mythic).
(Urszula Jarecka, Warsaw).
-
Jarvie,
I.C. 1970. Towards a sociology of the cinema. London:
Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Jarvie's
early work on cinema is a standard sociological take on
how the film industry functioned in the 1960s.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Jeffery, R. 2000. India's Newspaper Revolution: Capitalism, Politics and the Indian-Language Press
1977-99. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
The book provides an insightful analyses to the growth of newspaper industry in India since
independence to present time. India has witnessed newspaper revolution in terms of total number of
newspapers published and circulated. Especially Indian language newspapers have grown tremendously
since 1980s. The book attributes the growth of newspapers in India to: a) the rise of capitalism;
b) the information technology revolution; c) growth of advertising industry; d) rise in the
literacy level; e) interest in the political news.
(Taberez A. Neyazi, Singapore)
-
Jensen,
C.B. 2003. 'Communicating models: The relevance of models
for research on the worlds of the Internet', in S. Hjarvard
(ed.), Media in a globalized society. Copenhagen:
Museum Tusculanum Press.
This chapter contains a very interesting discussion of
the 'founding metaphors' to be found in Internet research,
grouped under three headings: the human-machine connection,
the human-human relation, and the human-machine-society
configuration (see Figure 1, p. 264).
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Johnson, K. 2001. Television and the Social Change in Rural India. New Delhi: Sage Publication.
The book is an ethnographic analyses of how advent of television played an important role in the
process of social change in rural India. The author examines its influence on gender roles, caste
and family relationships, aspirations, expectations and concerns of villagers. It studies the role
that villagers consider TV played in the social and economic development of the region. The author
contends that the role of TV has undergone change from that of educating, informing and
entertaining to only one aspect that is entertaining.
(Taberez A. Neyazi, Singapore)
K
-
Kemper,
S. 2001. Buying and believing. Sri Lankan advertising
and consumers in a transnational world. Chicago: University
of Chicago Press.
This
analysis of the Sri Lankan advertising industry and Sri
Lankan identity is a useful account of local adoptions
of and resistances to global marketing forces.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Kerr,
D. 1995. 'Popular Theatre & Macro-Media' (chapter
5), in African Popular Theatre. From Pre-colonial Times
to the Present Day. Oxford: Currey, Portsmouth: Heinemann,
Cape Town: David Philip, Harare: Baobab, Nairobi: EAEP,
p.172-195.
The chapter is part of a historical overview of the performance
arts in Africa. In the fifth chapter, Kerr describes the
various performance genres that have originated since
the entry of aural and visual mass media. Drawing upon
data from a whole range of Sub-Sahara African countries,
he shows how radio, television and cinema have gradually
been taken over by postcolonials and thus been indigenised.
(Katrien Pype, Leuven)
-
Kinsella,
Sh. 2000. Adult Manga. ConsumAsiaN Series. London:
Curzon.
Sharon
Kinsella has provided a comprehensive account of the Japanese
manga or cartoon publishing industry, based on fieldwork
and interviews with editors.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Kumar, S. 2006. Gandhi Meets Primetime: Globalization ad Nationalism
in Indian Television. Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
Shanti Kumar's book, in which he examines television programs, print
advertisements, and publicity brochures, demonstrates the transformation of
the national media and the national identity in the postcolonial India
through the influence of transnational and translocal media networks.
Kumar's research in India illuminates the struggle for hegemony between the
national and the global forces of capitalism and the role of media,
specifically the television's in this struggle.
(Yesim Kaptan, Indiana)
L
-
Lie,
R. 2003. Spaces of intercultural communication. An
interdisciplinary introduction to communication, culture
and globalizing/localizing identities. Cresskill,
N.J.: Hampton Press.
This volume explores spaces where cultures meet and mix
in entangled flows and levels of globality and locality.
It makes a contribution to our understanding of the complex
processes of communications across and beyond borders.
It provides an introduction to intercultural/international
communication and changing identities. Through its interdisciplinary
approach it integrates theories from communication studies,
cultural studies, media studies and social anthropology.
The book consists of three major parts and eight chapters.
The first part specifically addresses the concepts of
communication and culture. The second addresses globalizing/localizing
identities. Chapters in the third part theorize the spaces
in which these processes take place and use the socio-cultural
phenomenon of television as an example to focus on the
interdisciplinary potential of television studies.
(Rico Lie, Wageningen)
-
Lie,
R. 2003. 'Anthropolgy and television studies', in: Spaces
of intercultural communication. An interdisciplinary introduction
to communication, culture and globalizing/localizing identities,
151-179. Cresskill, N.J.: Hampton Press.
This chapter explores three dimensions of the existing
relations between anthropology and television studies.
First, the anthropological study of media, which is concerned
with the fundamental academic study of television. Subfields
addressed here are: (1) the introduction and circulation
of television; (2) producers of ethnographies, and; (3)
soap operas and telenovelas. Second, the fourfold area
of applied media anthropology, international communication,
development communication and participatory communication
research for social change, which are primarily concerned
with communication across social, cultural, political
and economic borders. They are connected to anthropology,
yet situated outside the discipline of anthropology itself.
Third, television studies within cultural media studies
and communication studies. Here the lines of interdisciplinarity
point to anthropological theories, methodologies and philosophies
that have entered the mixture of communication, media
and cultural studies. The four lines that are identified
are: (1) myth, ritual and symbols; (2) cultural globalization/localization;
(3) audience ethnographies, and (4) the anthropological
philosophy. After having reviewed these areas of intersection,
the chapter formulates arguments towards a new generation
of anthropological television studies.
(Rico Lie, Wageningen)
-
Liebes,
T. and J. Curran (eds.). 1998. Media, ritual and identity.
London: Routledge.
An excellent collection of studies, a tribute paid to
Elihu Katz. The majority of the studies are focused on
different media events, giving seminal theoretical insides.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
-
Lule,
J. 2001. Daily news, eternal stories. The mythological
role of journalism. New York: The Guilford Press.
The most elaborate embodiment of archetypal approach in
media studies. Lule considers both news and myths to be
the actualization of eternal stories, or archetypes, that
have marked mankindís history and destiny since
the most ancient times. Lule identifies 7 mythic archetypes
actualized by modern news: the victim, the scapegoat,
the hero, the good mother, the trickster, the other world,
and the flood.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
M
-
Machado-Borges,
T. 2003. Only for You! Brazilians and the telenovela
flow. Stockholm Studies in Social Anthropology. Stockholm:
Almqvist & Wiksell International.
The book focuses on the reception of a popular and commercial
mass-media product - Brazilian 'soap-operas', or telenovelas.
Ethnographic fieldwork conducted during several periods
between 1995 and 2000, in the state of Minas Gerais, south-eastern
Brazil, has shown that outside of the context of immediate
telenovela reception, people talked extensively not only
about the contents and characters of these programs, but
also about subjects and products that derived from or
entangled with the telenovela plot. The term 'telenovela
flow' is used in order to describe and visualize this
crucial part of informants' receptive experience. The
book explores the contents of the telenovela flow, tracing
and identifying some of its articulations and interspersions,
and relating them to contemporary Brazilian society. It
also examines the way the telenovela flow hails and interpellates
the viewer to interact with it. The telenovela flow presents
hierarchies of gender, sexuality, race and class as embodied
and naturalized, yet also tangible and immediate ways
of transcending or at least circumventing these very hierarchies.
Engaging with the telenovela flow viewers evaluate, scrutinize,
and search for ways to reinforce or transform their positions
as subjects within Brazilian society.
(Thais Machado-Borges, Stockholm)
Published review:
Halstead, N. 2006. Social Anthropology, 14/2, 287-288.
-
Malefyt,
T.W. and B. Moeran (eds.). 2003. Advertising cultures.
Oxford: Berg.
The volume explores relationships between anthropology
and advertising practices, and includes useful chapters
by Kemper, Miller, Lien and others.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
This volume is a collection of articles about the production
of advertisements in different cultural settings. How
do advertisers produce the strategies of persuasion? Which
assumptions do they make about products and consumers?
And how do they negotiate them during the making of campaigns?
(Ursula Rao, Halle)
-
Mankekar,
P. 1999. Screening culture, viewing politics. An ethnography
of television, womanhood, and nation in postcolonial India.
Durham: Duke University Press.
A
good audience ethnography with heavy reliance on content
analysis of popular soap operas in India. Though there
is not much focus on the production itself, it could be
read as how broader social and political environments
(such as the rise of nationalism) influence the production.
(Erkan Saka, Rice)
-
Manning,
P. 2001. News and news sources. A critical introduction.
London: Sage.
This
is a comprehensive overview of the studies that analyse
the relations between journalists and their sources and
the way news is constructed in interaction. It is a well
written introduction that provides an overview over the
theoretical interests that guided different studies and
the conclusion that were drawn.
(Ursula Rao, Halle)
-
Mano, W. 2007.
'Popular music as journalism in Zimbabwe', Journalism Studies 8(1): 61-78.
Mano has shown how popular music function
as journalism in Zimbabwe, where mass media are weak, opposition political parties are frail and the state
exerts strong control over the media.
(Herman Wasserman, Newcastle University)
-
Marcus,
G. (ed.). 1996. Connected: engagements with media.
University of Chicago Press.
The volume uses interview format to demonstrate the developments
in mass media studies, particularly in the new media.
The aim is to give some anthropological insights for future
ethnographic studies in these fields. Most of the interviewees
are media producers.
(Erkan Saka, Rice)
-
Marcus,
G. (ed.). 1997. Cultural producers in perilous states:
editing events, documenting change (Late editions: cultural
studies for the end of the century). Chicago: Chicago
University Press.
The format and aim of the book is similar to the Connected
volume. This is an attempt to study media producers whose
locations are considered to be marginal to the high-tech
global centres. To a certain extent, this volume can also
be considered to study of activism through media usage.
I feel this volume has intellectual affinity to Media
worlds. Anthropology on new terrain (Ginsburg et al).
(Erkan Saka, Rice)
-
Marshall,
J. 2001. 'Cyberspace or Cybertopos: The creation of online space', Social Analysis 45(1): 81-102.
Online 'space' is created by the structures of communication, the patterns of naming
and exchange which eventuate and by offline categorizations and uses of space. Online space both
expresses and reflects the status, productivity and aims of participants and produces a 'mood', or
mode of being, which can stabilize the divergence of meaning in such a world.
(Jon Marshall, Sydney)
-
Marshall,
J. 2002. 'The Sexual Life of Cyber-Savants', The Australian Journal of Anthropology
14(2): 229-248.
The paper investigates the role of netsex within an internet mailing list, and the
spillage of that sexual contact into offlist and offline life. Netsex stabilises divergence of
meaning, and is part of the framing conventions which revolve around the problems of authenticity.
(Jon Marshall, Sydney)
-
Marshall, J.
2004. 'Governance, Structure and Existence: Authenticity, Rhetoric, Race and Gender
on an Internet Mailing List', Proceedings of The Australian Electronic Governance Conference 2004,
Centre for Public Policy, University of Melbourne.
Online: http://www.public-policy.unimelb.edu.au/egovernance/papers/21_Marshall.pdf
This paper based on the study of the governance of the Cybermind mailing list argues that there are three main factors
influencing internet
governance: 1) the organisation of communication (whether the forum is a mailing list, MOO,
Newsgroup, weblog etc. ; 2) existential issues of 'being' online (such as suspension of being,
flame, and patterns of exchange); and 3) the rhetorical mobilization of offline categories.
(Jon Marshall, Sydney)
-
Marshall, J.
2006a. 'Negri, Hardt, Distributed Governance and Open Source Software', Portal:
Journal of Multidisciplinary International Studies 3(1).
Online: http://epress.lib.uts.edu.au/ojs/index.php/portal/article/view/122
The paper argues that distributed governance is not inherently democratic, but devolves responsibility elsewhere, making
it harder to
confront power. Furthermore the internet is not always a model of democracy and it is argued that
those involved in the construction of free and open source software are fraught with the problems
which affect people in information capitalism in general.
(Jon Marshall, Sydney)
-
Marshall, J.
2006b. 'Categories, Gender and Online Community', E-Learning 3(2).
Online: http://www.wwwords.co.uk/elea/content/pdfs/3/issue3_2.asp
This paper presents a sketch for a theory of the rhetorics involved in categorisation and the creation of culture in
online communities. It is argued that the meaning of categories depends upon the ways they are
framed. Among the most important ways of framing online by Westerners are Space, Public and
Private, Authenticity, Gender and Community. The paper elaborates these ideas by means of exploring
the nature of online communication, power and the category of gender on the basis of the case study
of the Mailing List 'Cybermind'.
(Jon Marshall, Sydney)
-
Mazzarella,
W. 2003. Shoveling smoke. Advertising and globalization
in contemporary India. Durham: Duke University Press.
This
is a rich and very interesting ethnography about Indian
advertisement culture. It shows how advertisements are
made, consumers constructed and images of India and Indian
products created. Theoretically the book advances an argument
about the making and unmaking of cultural differences
in a globalized (or better glocalized) world economy.
(Ursula Rao, Halle)
-
Mazzarella,
W. 2004. 'Culture, globalization, mediation', Annual
Review of Anthropology 33: 345-367.
A review of the literature on media and globalization.
The review claims that several key strands of globalization
studies have tended to reproduce substantialist and essentialist
models of culture. The author suggests an alternative
ethnographic and theoretical strategy on the basis of
a general theory of media and mediation.
(Hannah Knox, Manchester)
-
Meyer B., Moors A.
(eds.) 2006. Religion, Media, and the Public Sphere.
Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
This edited volume provides an overview of the current forms of
religious mediation, the proliferation of religion in the public sphere,
and the blurring of the boundaries between entertainment and religion.
It analyses how leaders or more subaltern practitioners of Pentecostal,
Hindu, Muslim and indigenous movements (for example
Israelian Jews or Australian Aborigines) use sound and image to
mediate personal identities, religious experiences and often alternative realms of belonging. The combination of
ethnographic material and theoretical reflections contributes to the high
quality of the texts. Very interesting and innovative.
(Katrien Pype, Leuven).
-
Miller, D. and Slater D. 2000. The Internet: An Ethnographic Approach.
Oxford: Berg.
A first of its kind when published, this book is cast as a classic
anthropological monograph focused on a 'place' (Trinidad), and aims at
showing how internet may be approached ethnographically, in the
substantively broader anthropological sense of that term. Drawing on
Miller's previous extensive work in Trinidad, it situates internet
engagements in terms of social networks and relationships, national
identity, economic history and pursuits, and religious practices.
(Jens Kjaerulff, Victoria)
-
Mithen,
S. 1996. The Prehistory of the Mind: The Cognitive
Origins of Art, Religion and Science. London and New
York: Thames & Hudson.
Of special interest to the study of media are Mithen's
palaeoanthropological models of the relationship between
the origins of art and the emergence of 'cognitive fluidity'
in humans' modular minds as recently as 60,000 to 30,000
years ago. Highly speculative work, but well worth the
read nonetheless.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Moeran,
B. 1996. A Japanese advertising agency. An anthropology
of media and markets. ConsumAsiaN Series. London:
Curzon.
This
study of a Japanese advertising agency is the first of
its kind, and provides a detailed analysis of the industry,
while also including an exemplary case study of a contact
lens campaign.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Moeran,
B. (ed.). 2001. Asian media productions. ConsumAsiaN
Series, London: Curzon.
Asian
Media Productions looks at how media forms are produced
and consumed in the Asian region. It includes chapters
by Ulf Hannerz, Mark Hobart, Koichi Iwabuchi, James Lull,
and others.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Morley, D. 2000. Home Territories. Media, Mobility and Identity. London and New York: Routledge.
Home is no longer a stable concept/place, but the point where global and local trends intersect. The author looks at home from various
perspectives: the national construction of the homeland, the gendering of the home, the role of media in opening the home to the global and
in prescribing the model family, the effects of mobility, migration and urban spaces on the home and finally, the recreation of communities
and new boundaries in virtual space. The book isnít based on original research, rather it is a collection of essays on the various facets of
home and the role of new communication technologies in both opening up and closing down this ever changing private/public space.
(Delia Dumitrica, Calgary)
-
Morley,
D. 1992. Television, audiences and cultural studies.
London: Routledge.
This
is one of the works that established ethnographic approaches,
especially focus group work, as a methodololgy in media
studies. There is an interesting survey of psychoanalytic
approaches to media, as well as of models of transmission,
followed up by the classic piece of focus group work on
'The Nationwide Audience'.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
N
-
Nyamnjoh,
F.B. 2005. Africa's Media. Democracy & the Politics
of Belonging. London: Zed Books.
Nyamnjoh offers an interesting account of the mass media
of Sub-Saharan Africa through the prism of the struggle
for democratisation. The book balances well between general
assumptions about the printed, spoken and digital communication
systems in Africa and a detailed analysis of the power
positions within the diverging media forms in Cameroon.
Throughout the book, he argues that media in Africa have
not yet been domesticated, i.e. brought closer to local
notions of personhood and agency. African journalists
are focussing too much upon 'citizens' denying the 'subject'
identity of Africans. Njamnjoh states that Africans are
both citizens and subjects, with a constant shift between
them. Mass media has to consider this in order to take
part in the democratisation process in a more clear and
constructive way.
(Katrien Pype, Leuven)
O
-
Osorio,
F. 2001. Mass media anthropology. Unpublished Ph.D.
thesis: University of Chile.
According
to the author the transmission of culture through mass
media is the object of study in mass media anthropology.
The dissertation is a kind of literature review on the
connections of mass media studies, communication studies
and anthropology.
(Pille Runnel, Tartu)
P
-
Peterson,
M.A. 2003. Anthropology and mass communication. Media
and myth in the new millennium. New York and Oxford:
Berghahn Books.
An attempt of bringing together scattered strands of media
research with the aim of establishing media anthropology
as a full-right sub-discipline. These strands come from
various ways of looking at media practices through anthropological
lenses as well as from non-anthropological studies of
mass communication and mediation that nevertheless contain
valuable insights for anthropologists. The author surveys
a variety of theoretical approaches to media and produces
an interdisciplinary review of research done in this area
in the second half of the twentieth century. His account
goes beyond simple enumeration of the trends already existing
and attempts drawing a more coherent yet non-binding picture
of the field.
(Anna Horolets, Warsaw)
-
Postill,
J. 2003. 'The life and afterlife crises of Saribas Iban
television sets', Media@lse Electronic Working Papers,
no 5.
This paper discusses the exchange of television sets among
the Iban of Sarawak, in Malaysian Borneo. It focuses on
two critical stages in the 'careers' of Iban televisions:
their acquisition and their disposal. This approach captures
these media artefacts as they transit through the gift
and exchange systems that bind rural and urban Iban, as
well as the living and the dead. One form of transit are
burial rites at which television sets are destroyed so
that the deceased can still enjoy their favourite programmes
in the Afterlife - an upside-down world were only broken
things work.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
Online: http://www.lse.ac.uk/collections/media@lse/mediaWorkingPapers/listOfTitles.htm
-
Postill,
J. 2003. 'Knowledge,
literacy, and media among the Iban of Sarawak: a reply
to Maurice Bloch', Social Anthropology (11)
1: 79-100. (PDF, 350 KB)
This article addresses the old divide between 'autonomous'
(Goody, Ong, etc) and 'ideological' (Street, Bloch, etc)
approaches to the cross-cultural study of literacy. Whilst
the autonomous model highlights the world historical links
between literacy and processes such as state-building,
scientific development, etc, the ideological model explores
the huge diversity of 'literacies' around the globe. The
author proposes a synthesis of the two approaches on the
basis of historical and ethnographic evidence from the
Iban of Sarawak, a state in Malaysian Borneo. He also
suggests that there is a strong analogy between the ideological
model and the 'appropriationist' paradigm that currently
prevails within the anthropological study of media.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Postill, J. 2006. Media and Nation Building: How the
Iban Became Malaysian. New York: Berghahn Books.
Media and Nation Building is an intellectually
engaging and thought-provoking book, and is a rich
contribution to several arenas within anthropology.
Media and Nation Building provides an analysis of the
processes by which the Iban (one of the ethnic groups
in Sarawak often referred to as Dayak) have been
incorporated into the modern Malaysian state. What
Postill argues is that the Malaysian state's nation
building program has been overwhelmingly successful.
The state's Malaysianization propaganda became
'sustainable propaganda' (analogous to sustainable
development), which in turn became an ideolect, an
Iban remaking of the state ideology though which they
make sense of the various media and ultimately their
world.
In their nation building project the Malaysian state
has controlled and employed various media, which
Postill productively takes to include not only
television, radio and newspapers, but clock and
calendar time. That inclusive definition of media
leads to a breadth of analysis in Media and Nation
Building that researchers and teachers of media
anthropology, as well as those interested in
nationalism or political anthropology, should find
useful.
(Gordon T. Gray, Temple University)
Draft chapter and abstract online at: http://johnpostill.co.uk/
Published reviews:
Gray, G. 2007. American Anthropologist.
Mihelj, S. 2007. H-Nationalism.
Online: http://johnpostill.co.uk/
-
Postill, J. (in press) 'Localising the Internet beyond communities and
networks', New Media and Society. (PDF, 72 KB)
This article draws on ethnographic research among Internet activists in a suburb of Kuala Lumpur (Malaysia) to argue for the need to broaden the
current conceptual lexicon of Internet studies, particularly at the local level of analysis, to overcome their dependence on the paired notions of
community and network, e.g. in phrases such as 'community networks'.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
R
-
Rotherbuhler,
E.W. 1998. Ritual communication: from everyday conversation
to mediated ceremony. London: Sage.
The most clear and complete presentation of the relationship
between the communication studies and anthropology. The
author follows the way the anthropological theories about
ritual are applied in both interpersonal communication
and mass mediated communication.
(Mihai Coman, Bucharest)
-
Rothenbuhler,
E. and M. Coman (eds). 2005. Media Anthropology.
London: Sage.
This reader is a welcome, 30-chapter long contribution
to the two existing media anthropology readers (Askew
and Wilk 2002, Ginsburg et. al. 2002). It brings to this
research area a more interdisciplinary approach (Rothenbuhler
is a media scholar, not an anthropologist) as well as
an interest in 'classic' anthropological concerns such
as myth and ritual. In addition, it devotes a section
to the question of how anthropology can engage more effectively
with journalists and other media professionals (cf. Eriksen
2006).
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
S
-
Schroeder,
I.W. and S. Voell (eds.). 2002. Moderne Oralitaet.
Ethnologische Perspektiven auf die plurimediale Gegenwart.
[Modern orality.] Marburg: Curupira.
This
edited volume states that there are structural similarities
between primordial orality and current forms of communication.
The revitalisation of orality provides a socially accepted
and culturally more appropriate communicative strategy
to the predominantly oral societies of the periphery.
In a variety of ethnographical case studies, from the
indigenous Southwest of the US to a German chat-community,
the phenomenon of 'modern orality' is analysed.
(Philipp Budka, Vienna)
-
Scollon,
R. and S. Wong Scollon. 2004. Nexus analysis. Discourse
and the emerging Internet. London and New York: Routledge.
An anthropology inspired analysis of the early stages
of the internet use in university teaching and other contexts
in Alaska. The authors offer a personal account of the
multiple shifts in discourse practices caused by the introduction
of the new medium of communication.
(Anna Horolets, Warsaw)
-
Skov,
L. and B. Moeran (eds.). 1995. Women, media and consumption
in Japan. ConsumAsiaN Series. London: Curzon.
This
book is now considered a 'classic' benchmark in studies
of Japanese media, and includes media-related studies
of different kinds of Japanese women - ranging from 40
year old 'traditional' types to teenage 'cuties'.
(Brian Moeran, Copenhagen)
-
Skuse,
A. 1999. Negotiated outcomes: an ethnography of the
production and consumption of a BBC World Service soap
opera for Afghanistan. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis: University
of London.
At
the height of the Taliban troubles, the author traces
the social life of a BBC radio soap all the way from the
production studios to its varied contexts of consumption.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Spitulnik,
D. 1993. 'Anthropology
and mass media', Annual Review of Anthropology
22: 293-315. (PDF, 1,6 MB)
This is a comprehensive seeming review of the literature
relevant to anthropology and media, at the time (1993).
It covers most of the aspects that one might struggle
with in defining media anthropology. It calls particular
attention to issue in linguistic anthropology, and studies
of communication, as well as clearly laying out the shift
from text or message based analysis towards more contextual
and practice based approaches in Media Scholarship.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
The obligatory entry point to the anthropology of media
up until the early 21st century readers by Askew and Wilk
(2002), and Ginsburg et al (2002) were published - both
are annotated above. Still very useful today as an early
review and programmatic piece.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Spitulnik,
D. 1996. 'The
social circulation of media discourse and the mediation
of communities', Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
6: 161-187. (PDF, 2,8 MB)
A rare 'diffusionist' analysis of why certain types of
radio discourse spread and become part of a country's
public culture, with Zambia as the ethnographic case study.
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
-
Spitulnik,
D. 2002. 'Alternative
small media and communicative spaces', in G. Hyden,
M. Leslie and F. F. Ogundimu (eds.), Media and democracy
in Africa. New Brunswick,NJ, and London: Transaction.
[Published simultaneously with Uppsala: Nordic Africa
Institute]. (PDF, 1,2 MB)
Focuses on the role of small media in fostering civil
society in contexts where mass media are tightly controlled
and highly censored. Combining ethnography of communication
and media studies approaches, it examines how technological
parameters and cultural influences factor into small media
production and circulation, and discusses the differential
effects of variables such as technological access, verbal
culture, literacy, class, and gender in small media mobilization.
(Debra Spitulnik, Atlanta)
-
Stahlberg,
P. 2002. Lucknow daily. How a Hindi newspaper constructs
society. Stockholm Studies in Social Anthropology
51, Stockholm: Almqvist and Wiksell.
An ethnography that can roughly be placed within the subfield
of media production. The author attempts to supersede
the orthogonal visions of the mass media and locality
and to demonstrate the convergence and mutual dependencies
between the rootless and the rooted.
(Anna Horolets, Warsaw)
-
Street,
B. (ed.). 1993. Cross-Cultural approaches to literacy.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
This landmark volume captures a rich sample of ethnographic
studies of literacy around the world. Its authors subscribe
to the ideological model of literacy. In their view, literacy
practices are hugely diverse and always entangled with
power relations. They reject the autonomous model of literacy
(Goody, Ong, etc) with its notion of a world historical
great divide between orality and literacy. Instead they
explore context-specific oral/literate mixes in a range
of societies, the stress being on how ideology guides
literacy practices. There are strong parallels between
the ideological model and the implicitly ideological models
adopted by most anthropologists working on media practices
other than writing. Is writing/literacy a yet to be acknowledged
media practice?
(John Postill, Sheffield Hallam)
T
-
Taghioff,
D. 2005. 'Another Subject is Possible: Reporting in the
Indian Press on the World Social Forum (WSF)', SOAS
Literary Review, Spring 2005.
Online: http://www.soas.ac.uk/soaslit/2005_index.htm
This article is about the reporting on the World Social
Forum held in Mumbai. It explores the coverage in the
English Language Press of India, examining how various
contructions of the liberal/enlightenment self are found
in the political commentary. It then contrasts this with
the lack of coverage in vernacular language publications,
pointing out that another subject, in both senses of the
word, is possible.
(Daniel Taghioff, London)
-
Taureg,
M. and F. Wittmann (eds.). 2005. Entre tradition orale
et nouvelles technologies: ou vont les mass média
au Sénégal? Dakar: Enda Tiers Monde.
In 2003 the Goethe Institute in Dakar organised a series
of seminars on the Senegalese mass media. This volume
covers some of the more controversial and fascinating
issues to emerge from these meetings, including the immediacy
of local radio, the working conditions of journalists,
corruption, the informal sector, and the popular press.
The authors are mostly young media professionals, researchers
and lecturers.
(Frank Wittmann, Fribourg)
-
Tilic,
Dogan L. 1998. Utaniyorum ama gazeteciyim. Turkiyeíde
ve yunanistan | |